Showing posts with label John Smoltz. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Smoltz. Show all posts

Thursday, October 27, 2016

Reliving 1991 - Game 7: Just a Game

And now we've reached Game 7. After all the chaos and tension of the previous six games, this was the only possible way this Series could have ended. The series was destined for seven games from the start, and going in, there's no reason to believe this game will be anything but tight. The only question is if will live up to the previous six.

You know the pitching matchup by now: John Smoltz of the Braves against Jack Morris of the Twins. Morris was pitching for the team he cheered for as a child; Smoltz was pitching against the pitcher he idolized as a child.

The home team had won each of the first six games of the Series. As our broadcast begins with a shot of a packed-full Metrodome, the Twins have to feel good that they get to host the final game. After all, they've never lost a World Series game in the Dome.

Play by play here; video here.

Lonnie Smith shakes Brian Harper's hand. The fans start roaring as Morris takes the mound. And we're off.

Top 1 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Jack Morris pitching.

"And here he is. From Highland Park, a suburb of St. Paul, Jack Morris."

The game hasn't started yet, and Jack Buck has made a mistake; Highland Park is a neighborhood of St. Paul, not a suburb. I accept this mistake, though, because at least he didn't call St. Paul a suburb of Minneapolis.

Lonnie Smith flies to right. One out.

Don Denkinger is the home plate umpire. Cardinals fans hate him.

Pendleton grounds to first, unassisted. Two outs.

Whenever there was a game broadcast at the Dome, the announcers always felt the need to mention what it felt like outside. Tonight was apparently a "chilly, clear" night.

Ron Gant strikes out. Three outs.

Bottom 1 - Twins 0, Braves 0

John Smoltz: 8-1 after the All Star break, 2-0 against Pittsburgh in the NLCS (including Game 7). He was exactly who the Braves wanted on the mound for this one.

This World Series was the first in (Atlanta) Braves history, but they ended up going to five in the 1990s. This was the only one to go to Game 7.

Dan Gladden strikes out. One out.

Chuck Knoblauch flies to right. Two outs.

That ball was in the air forever. Seemed to defy gravity. The Braves staggered under it a little but Justice caught it cleanly.

And now Puckett. The fans give a roar, but it dies kind of quickly. The nervous tension is already taking over.

Here's the list of players to hit an extra-inning walkoff home run in the World Series, through Game 6, 1991: Dusty Rhodes, Eddie Mathews, Carlton Fisk, Kirby Puckett.

And since then: Chad Curtis, Derek Jeter, Alex Gonzalez, David Freese.

First 88 World Series: Four such instances. Next 19 World Series: Four such instances.

Kirby Puckett grounds to pitcher. Three outs.

Top 2 - Braves 0, Twins 0

David Justice singles to center.

Another ball falls in front of the too deep Puckett. That's at least three hits he's allowed for that reason.

Jack Buck said that hit almost makes up for Justice's near home run from Game 6. No, no it doesn't. That ball would have won the World Series if it had been fair. This was a second-inning single.

Sid Bream grounds to second, Justice to second. One out.

Justice was running on the play, so he didn't really have much of a chance. Same thing as a bunt.

Brian Hunter strikes out. Two outs.

I don't remember Morris getting a strike out on a high fastball like that in past game this series. Seems like he always went with the forkball.

Greg Olson flies to second. Three outs.

Bottom 2 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Tim McCarver is talking about tension, and numbness in the joints. They show Tom Glavine staring straight ahead, glazed look in his eyes, slowly cracking his knuckles. Reminder, this is the 2nd inning.

Kent Hrbek flies to right. One out.

They show Chili, and behind him, the Braves dugout. Leo Mazzone is rocking full force now. I think this is when it started. And it didn't stop the rest of his career.

Now we learn about Smoltz's path to the Braves. Originally drafted by Detroit, he was traded in the 1987 Doyle Alexander trade. Alexander went 9-0 with a 1.53 ERA down the stretch for Detroit in 1987 after the trade. Then he went 0-2 with a 10.00 ERA against the Twins in the ALCS that year and flamed out of baseball two years later. Smoltz, meanwhile, ended up in the Hall of Fame. So it goes.

Chili Davis strikes out looking. Two outs.

Brian Harper singles to center.

Now maybe Buck will stop counting down the number of consecutive batters Smoltz has retired. I get it when the number gets large, but not when it's the second inning.

Shane Mack is up. He got two hits in Game 6, so hopefully that stays with him tonight and gives him some confidence.

Shane Mack singles, Harper to second.

There we go. Although there are fewer things more frustrating than a pair of two-out singles. They just get you excited for no reason.

But, Mike Pagliarulo, who was 3-for-3 with a homer off Smoltz in Game 4, is up. McCarver is reminding us how pissed Smoltz was to give up that home run on a fastball. I think he should NOT remind him of that.

Mike Pagliarulo grounds to first, pitcher covering. Three outs.

Well, I tried.

Top 3 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Oh, nice, the Braves front office staff wears little Tomahawk-shaped lapel pins. How adorable.

Mark Lemke grounds to second. One out.

I enjoy not having to swear at Mark Lemke.

Everybody in the Braves dugout looks sick. Except Olson. He looks completely chill. Like he's thinking about hunting instead of baseball.

Rafael Belliard singles to right.

I feel like I've spelled his first name three different ways in these games. But I'm not going to look him up or even look to see if I've spelled it consistently.

Belliard to second on passed ball.

Less good.

I like Morris' guts, though. Harper made mince meat of a breaking ball on the passed ball, but Morris went right back to one on the next pitch.

The top of the third marks our first reference to the phrase "It's a shame somebody has to lose." There are probably some players who would take a tie right now.

Smith walks.

Probably another semi-intentional walk, although why they'd do that with Pendleton up next is a good question, so maybe not.

Pendleton flies to left. Two outs.

No issues with that one. Off the end of his bat, not deep at all.

Ron Gant is introduced as a "first-ball fastball hitter." So on the first pitch...

Gant grounds into a fielders choice, Smith out, short to second. Three outs.

Bottom 3 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Nick Esasky is shown on the Braves bench, even though he's described as having been on the disabled list for two years with vertigo. I mean, at some point they gotta tell him to stay home, right? And he never did play again.

Greg Gagne grounds to third. One out.

McCarver brings up that this is the first World Series to have three games end with a run being scored on the final swing of the bat. Possibly related, everybody has ulcers.

Gladden doubles to left.

The Gladdenstache wakes up. Wasn't a great looking swing, but it was well-placed down the left field line. I'm glad it's the Twins threatening now instead of the Braves.

Exterior shot of the Metrodome. There doens't appear to be any snow on the ground. Give it a few days. Four, to be exact.

Knoblauch flies to right, Gladden to third. Two outs.

Kirby's up with a runner on third. Hope he didn't use up all his magic last night.

They showed the Twins dugout for the first time. They don't look quite as stressed as the Braves one, but they're also not in a happy place right now.

Puckett strikes out. Three outs.

Jack Buck: "We have six more innings to go of torture and pleasure." As disturbing as that sounds, I ... I kinda like it. It's fitting.

Top 4 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Morris threw a palmball at Justice. That's so old school the ball was sepia-toned while going to the plate.

Justice strikes out. One out.

Bream flies to left. Two outs.

Hunter doubles to left.

Doubles are fine if there are two outs. McCarver gives us the helpful stat that it was the 40th extra-base hit in the World Series, which is two away from the record. I'm trying to remember the play-by-play, and I think we're only going to tie that record, not break it. CLIFFHANGER.

Lemke is on deck, which makes this current at bat with Olson the most important of the game. Morris HAS to get Olson.

(Yes, I have The Fear with Lemke. And I don't care how bizarre it is.)

The Twins dugout is full of players sitting with their elbows on their legs, hands folded nicely in their laps. It's like they're so desperate to not develop a nervous tick they're choosing to squeeze the life out of their own hands instead.

Olson flies to right. Three outs.

Mack started toward center on that ball, then ran hard in, catching it below his knees. In other words, it was terrifying.

Bottom 4 - Braves 0, Twins 0

"Tension fills the park," says Buck. He honestly can't handle this game. It's too much for him.

Hrbek hit by a pitch.

Um ... that ball didn't look like it hit Hrbek. It came awfully close to hitting his elbow, then bounced off Olson's glove and hit the umpire square in the thigh. While the umpire was grimacing, Hrbek pretended the ball hit him, and the ump believed him. Replays are inconclusive at best; if it hit him, it was just by the seams.

But whatever. The leadoff guy is on for the first time, and Chili is up.

Davis flies to left. One out.

Chili is no longer up.

Pat Olson. Not the same guy I
showed yesterday. I'm like 90% sure.
We are now introduced to Pat Olson (left), who has now attended 283 consecutive World Series games. If we assume that this game is actually 284, then that puts his streak as starting in Game 1 of 1946. (Because why would he start his streak in Game 2 of a series?) That's an awesome life.

(HINT Nicci)

Harper flies to right. Two outs.

Another awkward looking but effective play by Justice. He ran like one leg was two inches shorter than the other, but made a nice sliding catch to keep Hrbek on first.

Mack flies to second. Three outs.


Top 5 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Lemke singles to right.

I would like to kick Mark Lemke in the shins.

Now they're talking about how they're in automatic bunt territory here. It's hard to believe we've gotten that far in this game already, but they're right. I'm sure both managers know the first run is going to win this thing. So everybody expects Belliard to bunt, which he does.

Belliard sacrifices, catcher to first, Lemke to second. One out.

That was easy. He just bounced it straight down, took the Metrodome hop, and Harper had no chance at Lemke.

Smith singles to third, Lemke to third.

He was trying for a hit there, not a sacrifice. Then he slid feet first, as if to say "please get me out." Luckily for him, Pags' throw took Hrbek just barely off the bag, and he was safe. I've seen three replays, and I'm not convinced Hrbek pulled his foot. But the umpire had the best view. (Not sarcasm, either).

Still, though. Smith was a good hitter. Try to get Lemke home.

And now Pendleton is up; he's 10 for his last 11 (this is an approximation). I am not happy with these developments.

Pendleton flies to short. Two outs.

Buck said "pops him up for the second out," before Gagne was even under that ball. And then Gladden almost ran into him. Too close for my liking.

And now Gant is up. He was the Braves' second-best hitter in 1991 after Pendleton, but the Twins have been oddly unafraid of him. He did hit the ball that led to Puckett's Catch, but he hasn't been more than OK in the series, so they obviously had something on him.

The crowd is going in waves. They're silent between pitches and roaring when Morris is about to throw.

SO CLOSE! It's not in the play-by-play, but Morris just bounced one up there. Harper blocked it and it bounced about 15 feet in front of home plate. Lemke started to come, but Morris grabbed and threw back to third and almost got him. So, so close to a go-ahead run. So, so close to getting out of the inning at third.
Sorry for the blurry. I paused it right when Pags caught it.
He looks out, doesn't he?

And on replays ... I think they got him. I paused it, and I think he was out. The Twins thought he was out. I think Lemke kinda thought he was out. But he was safe.

And there was (of course) no replay challenges in 1991, and I'm glad. Just let the call stand.

(Easy to say now, 25 years later.)

(Also, I kinda want to puke.)

Then Morris almost picks off Smith, who is remarkably still at first despite what happened with Lemke. Smith has not been a good baserunner this series. That will become apparent one more time before we're done.

Gant strikes out looking. Three outs.

The Jack Morris arm pump. Gant took that ball without even flinching, and Morris responded with a long, exaggerated fist pump, one that looked more like a huge air guitar chord than anything else. Huge, huge moment.

Bottom 5 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Pagliarulo flies to center. One out.

Pags got us all excited there. Gant caught it on the run one step from the wall.

Buck is now begging us to not turn off the TV after the game is over because there will be something special. I will be happy to oblige if my DVD shows it. Partially because I won't be able to/want to move.

Gagne strikes out. Two outs.

Gladden singles to center.

Gladden's second hit, and the fourth in the game for the Twins. Two bad there's two outs. But Kirby's one batter away, so we just need Knoblauch to somehow get on. Maybe he can lean into one.

Knoblauch flies to center. Three outs.

He did not lean into one. It's hard to lean into one that's over the heart of the plate. Darn.

Top 6 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Justice grounds to first, pitcher covering. One out.

Good job by Hrbek to not panic there. The short hop kind of ate him up there, but he stayed calm and tossed it to Morris with time to spare.

Bream grounds to first, unassisted. Two outs.

Are they trying to test if Hrbek is awake? Because he is. He looks like he hasn't slept in a week, but he's awake.

Hunter is up. He apparently spent the last half inning flexing his hand, unsure if he could swing. It even got to the point that a pinch-hitter grabbed his bat and got ready. But Hunter stayed in there.

Hunter flies to center. Three outs.

Morris has his first 1-2-3 inning since the first. And Puckett, Hrbek, and Davis are coming up. 1991 me is thinking that if they don't win it here, they might not win it. I have a tension headache (present day me, that is.)

Bottom 6 - Braves 0, Twins 0

We are told that Washington beat the Giants today 17-13 to become the last undefeated team in the NFL. Because we want a fucking football score right now.

(Washington would finish that season 14-2 and go on to win the Super Bowl ... in the Metrodome.)

Puckett walks.

That's his first unintentional walk of the Series. And now the leadoff batter is on, with three good hitters coming up, and Puckett has decent speed, and oh man the Twins are gonna win and it's awesome.

Hrbek is 0 for his last 14, although he got hit by a pitch his last time up, so maybe the streak is over.

Hrbek honestly looks exhausted. Like he's gonna fall over any minute. It must be taking literally all his energy to swing these full swings.

Hrbek flies to center. One out.

Gant barely moved. Puckett wasn't able to move, either.

But Chili's up, and he's homered twice this series, so why not another one? Time to win.

Davis grounds into a double play, first to short to first, Puckett out at second. Three outs.

I'm literally speechless. That was so fast.

Top 7 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Bream is rubbing somebody's earlobes in the dugout. I don't know whose ears they were. I don't want to look it up because I'm nervous and I need to get some Advil.

Olson strikes out. One out.

Morris completely overpowered him.

Lemke flies to center. Two outs.

Lemke's at bat was so quick I didn't get a chance to be nervous that he was batting.

Rafael Belliard chokes up like an inch and a half. It looks like he weights 105 pounds. It's amazing players who look like that can have a big league career.

Belliard strikes out. Three outs.

Belliard was openly trying to walk there. Morris realized he had no intention on swinging and just poured the last two down the middle.

Bottom 7 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Morris and Smoltz have been remarkably calm this game. I'm sure their hearts were racing, but they haven't betrayed that at all.

Harper grounds to third. One out.

Mack grounds to third. Two outs.

Smart play by Mack. Pendleton was way back, and he's had a sore leg, and it was a decent bunt. Problem is the turf was so fast that it got to Pendleton quickly and gave him a chance to get the out.

Pagliarulo grounds to third. Three outs.

Quit hitting to him, huh?

Top 8 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Smith singles to right.

Smith didn't want to swing at that. He checked up, made contact anyway, and it fell in front of Mack.

And now Pendleton's up. They're wondering if Smith will try to steal or if Pendleton will bunt, but I'm having a hard time paying attention, because my legs are bouncing nervously. They have been for a while and I just now noticed it, so I think this counts as cardio? I'm not sure.

The bullpen is going for the Twins. Morris might be tiring. This is dumb.

Son of a! Pendleton got a two-strike foul-tip. Harper claimed he caught it, and the home plate umpire didn't see it and asked for help, but it very clearly bounced. So still two strikes.

Morris is about to throw his 100th pitch.

Pendleton doubles to left, Smith to third.

Oh dear God. Morris' 100th pitch is drilled to left center, and it bounces high off the plexiglass. Gladden had to wait for what seemed like ages for it to come down, then fired to the infield, only to find that, somehow, Smith was only at third.

Smith pulling up as Knoblauch pretends to throw him out at
second, with Gagne in on the act.
Smith apparently got deked by Knoblauch as he was running to third - Knoblauch faked a throw to Gagne, as if it was a double play, with Gagne even running to the base to keep up the act. Smith saw that, stopped at second, and hopped for a solid three seconds before running to third.

He's had two bad baserunning plays so far this series, but this third and final one was by far the worst. There is no way a guy fast enough to be a leadoff hitter shouldn't have scored on that play. The Twins got so, so lucky.

And yet, it's still second and third with nobody out.

Gant is up, and first base is open, and they're fjkhkdaswl PITCHING TO HIM!??! Wait .. Justice is on deck. I'm sure Kelly trusts the righty-righty matchup instead of Morris vs. Justice. So it makes sense.

Gant grounds to first. One out.

Man, Kelly looked smart there.

And he'll look even smarter here. He walks slowly to the mound to talk to Morris himself: "Who would you rather face, Justice or Bream?" Kelly walks off the mound and leaves Morris there, leading to a big cheer from the crowd.

Justice walks intentionally.

Morris has spoken. It's up to Bream. Bases loaded, one out. Still no score. A man is eating a foam tomahawk in the stands. My neck is sore.

Kelly's relievers (Bedrosian and Guthrie) are ready to go. But he left Morris in there. Balls of steel there from the manager.

Bream fouls off three or four pitches. I stopped counting because I can no longer count. Then he hits one to Hrbek. The play is to home.

Bream grounds into a double play, first to catcher to first, Smith out at home. Three outs.

Of all the pitches Jack Morris threw in his life, none were bigger than that. That play increased the Twins' chances of winning the game - and, by extension, the championship - by 29 percent. The website Grantland determined that it was the 12th most valuable play in baseball history since 1947, and the only one of the top 15 that was a defensive play. That makes it the most valuable pitch ever thrown. A career-defining, World Series-saving pitch.

Hrbek does a double fist pump in celebration, then bounces the ball in celebration. The crowd is roaring. I have goosebumps, 25 years after it happened. What a play. What a game. What a series.

Bottom 8 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Randy Bush hitting.

Bush singles to center.

Damn, Randy! One pitch and you did your job! I completely forgot he played in this game. It's the start of a rally. Time to win a World Series.

Al Newman running.

At this point, Buck can only say "wow-o-wow-o-wow." He's completely done. We're all just along for the ride at this point. Nobody has any clue what's happening.

Gladden's trying to bunt Newman over. It's not going well.

Gladden flies to center. One out.

Smoltz made mincemeat of him there.

Knoblauch singles to right, Newman to third.

One pitch after saying you can't hit-and-run on a pitcher like Smoltz, the Twins hit-and-run on a pitcher like Smoltz. The Series-winning run in on third, and Kirby Puckett is at bat. I feel like I'm in a fever dream.

Cox is walking to the mound. Smoltz looks furious, then frustrated. He can't believe he's getting taken out. He can't believe he didn't get the job done.

Mike Stanton pitching.

They didn't bring in Stanton to face Puckett. They're walking him to load the bases and get to Hrbek, who is 0-for-3 against Stanton this series. McCarver is describing this like it's incredibly controversial and/or ballsy, but it makes sense to me.

So Kent Hrbek can win the World Series now. Bases loaded, one out. Just like the Braves had in the top of the inning. This game is beyond comprehension at this point.

Hrbek lines into a double play to second, Knoblauch out, second unassisted.

My god. Dear god.

Top 9 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Newman playing short.

I'm not sure anybody is even having fun at this point. This is just excruciating.

Hunter grounds to third. One out.

Olson grounds to short. Two outs.

Not really sure you should be swinging first-pitch at a pitcher who is well over 100 pitches in the 9th inning, but that's what Olson did. I approve of the result.

Now Lemke is up in the 9th inning of the 7th game of a series in which he's been awesome. I don't like that he's up. He's not a home run guy, but he has three triples this series. I wish it wasn't Lemke.

They show a woman with bright red nails looking completely miserable in the stands, and McCarver tries a bad pun about how Lemke is trying to "nail" one. I mean, at least he's trying.

Lemke strikes out. Three outs.

Lemke's magic is done. And Jack Morris just threw 9 innings of shutout ball in the 7th game of the World Series.

 Bottom 9 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Davis, Harper, and Mack are due up in the 9th. I would appreciate it if Chili just ripped one out of here and take us out of our misery. So anytime now Chili.

He's trying to listen. His swings haven't exactly been compact here. But now with two strikes, he has to shorten his swing a bit. Right?

He's fouled off several pitches. He's got Stanton measured. He's not scared of the situation.

Davis singles to right.

CHILI! A great at bat and it pays off. The World Series-winning run is on first.

Jarvis Brown running.

Will something called Jarvis Brown actually score the Series-winning run? No way, right?

Harper shows bunt, and Stanton almost hits the backstop. I think Stanton might be a bit amped up.

Ooh, the corner infielders charge, and Harper swings away. Then he bunts on the next pitch.

Harper singles to pitcher, Brown to second.

Stanaton and Bream both went for it, neither got it. The second baseman was running to first to cover, so Stanton had to chase the ball all the way to the second-base line, and he pulled something doing it. He's gotta come out.

So, the Braves have to make an injury replacement for their pitcher in the bottom of the 9th. Because of course.

Alejandro Pena pitching.

Mack is up. McCarver is again talking about bunting, and Mack shows the bunt but it goes foul. Lots of bunts this inning. And really, all you need is one (similar to All You Need is Love), so get those runners closer.

Mack grounds into a double play, second to short to first, Brown to third. Two outs.

That was a great turn by Lemke. Falling away from second, and throwing around Harper, and he gets the ball to second in time for Belliard to get it back to first. That took the air out of the stadium, which is understandable, but also weird, since the Series-winning run is still on third.

Pagliarulo walks intentionally.

Al Newman was on deck. He's not going to bat here, though.

Paul Sorrento hitting.

I don't like this option for the guy with the game on the line, mostly because I didn't remember that he played for the Twins in 1991 until I started watching these games again. Why is he batting here? Leius is still on the bench - and, presumably, will have to come in if Sorrento fails here - so why not let him bat? He's seen more pitches lately too.

Ugh. I can't stand this. Just win this thing already!

The infielders are all playing super far back, like all of them almost in the outfield. Can't Sorrento bunt? I know he's a power guy, but just drop it down and see what you can do. Keep it fair, you win the Series.

Sorrento strikes out. Three outs.

Ugh. Stupid.

Top 10 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Scott Leius playing short.

How is this game still happening? How has nobody scored? This isn't possible. This has been absolutely remarkable.

Honestly, this game was taken out of the players' hands a long time ago. I believe I've written this before, but this series should really be considered a tie. Starting about the 8th inning, it turned into a giant cosmic coin flip. Somebody is going to win only because somebody must. There are no ties in championships. But both these teams deserve it.

And Jack Morris is still on the mound, warming up for the 10th. Apparently during the ninth, Kelly went to him and thanked him for the game. Morris said there was no way on earth he was coming out. Kelly responded with "Ok, it's just a game."

Just a game.

And so Morris is on the mound for the 10th. And it's obvious he would have been there, if needed, for the 11th, the 12th ... who knows how long? Kelly didn't appear to have a gun with him in the dugout, so maybe he wouldn't have been able to take him out at all.

Jeff Blauser hitting.

Blauser pops to catcher. One out.

Harper drifted back, unable to see that ball. Then at the last moment, he saw it and caught it right up against the fence. I wonder if we've seen the result of the cosmic coin flip.

Lonnie Smith, the goat of the moment, is up.

Our first view of Ted Turner in the stands, and he looks like he's about to fall asleep. I know he's just relieving the tension, like everybody in the Dome, but the timing of the camera shot was bad.

Smith strikes out. Two outs.

Morris' fastball is just as fast in the 10th as it was in the 1st. Remarkable.

Pendleton grounds to short. Three outs.

Somehow, Morris' 10th inning of work might have been his cleanest. Maybe the Braves are just done.

Bottom 10 - Braves 0, Twins 0

Blauser playing short.

A lot of the innings I've seen while rewatching this Series were so unfamiliar to me that they may as well have been happening live. But the bottom of the 10th? I've got this one memorized.

The Gladdenstache is leading off. He swings at the first pitch and saws his bat in half. A little blooper into shallow left that takes a high hop off the turf, over Hunter. Gant is right there to back him up, and is up firing to second, but Gladden, who never stopped running, beats it by a whisker.

Gladden doubles to left.

Knoblauch's up. He has one job: Get Gladden to third, any way possible. The crowd is roaring, but now there are no nerves behind that roar: It's one of anticipation. It feels like, finally, this is it. This is where it happens. Knoblauch gets the bunt down.

Knoblauch sacrifices to third. Gladden to third. One out.

Puckett's up, and the crowd doesn't roar as loud as they normally would for their hero, because they know: Puckett's getting walked. There's no way he gets to swing a bat this inning.

Puckett walks intentionally.

The outfielders are coming in now, standing where they can catch a ball flat-footed and still throw out Gladden at third. Any Twin that can hit it deep wins the series.

Hrbek walks intentionally.

Jarvis Brown is on deck, but he's not going to swing. Gene Larkin grabs a bat.

Gene Larkin hitting.

He can barely run - his leg is visibly swollen. If he hits it on the ground, the inning is probably over. But if he hits it in the air...

Larkin singles to left, Gladden scores. Twins 1-0.

............................................

The Twins are celebrating like mad on the field, but it gets subdued pretty quickly. They're all clearly spent. They won the series, sure, but it's more like they survived it.

The Braves are stunned in their dugout. They're too tired to truly show sadness, or any other emotion. Just blank stares.

As the Twins celebration breaks up, the cameras show a different site: Jack Morris shaking hands with Ron Gant, Brian Hunter walking away after congratulating another Twin. There's no animosity here; the Braves are gracious in defeat, the Twins humble.

It's not a common site to see the losing team shaking hands with the winning team during the on-field World Series championship celebration, but it's because the players are fully aware of what just happened. They didn't so much play in the World Series as much as they witnessed it. They were just as much a part of the audience as we were. They fully grasped the magnitude of what took place in these seven games, and they knew they were lucky to be a part of it.

It was 25 years ago today that Dan Gladden jogged home and jumped on home plate, ending the greatest World Series ever played. It seems like a lifetime ago, but the memory is fresh. Whenever the Twins win their next World Series, whether it's next season or 25 years from now, the celebration will be long and loud, and Twins fans will be overjoyed. But there will also be something in the back of our minds: Sure, winning that future World Series will be great, but it still won't quite compare to the magical 9 days in October of 1991.

Sunday, October 23, 2016

Reliving 1991 - Game 4: Seriously, just watch home plate

Welcome to Game 4 of the 1991 World Series. Game 3 ended about 14 minutes ago, but for some reason the two teams have to come out and do this again. We’re starting to reach the breaking point in this game, going from “this is a pretty good series” to “this series is life-changing” over the next nine innings.

On the mound: John Smoltz, who went 12-2 in the second half of the season and had, two wins against Pittsburgh in the NLCS, including a shutout in Game 7. He’s going up against Jack Morris, who I talked about in Game 1. He’s 3-0 this postseason and is 6-1 in the postseason at this exact moment in his career.

John vs. Jack. It begs the question: Why is Jack a nickname for John?

Anyway, the play-by-play and boxscore are here, and the video of the game is here.

Top 1 – Twins 0, Braves 0

John Smoltz pitching.

Dan Gladden grounds to short. One out.

If you had “announcer mentions the fast infield” on your 1991 World Series bingo card, mark ’er down.

Chuck Knoblauch doubles to right.

He swung one handed at a pitch six inches off the ground and blooped it with six inches of the right field foul line for a double. It’s really too bad Knoblauch completely flamed out, because he keeps doing things in this series that reminds me of just how good he was.

Kirby Puckett flies to right. Two outs.

Another bad swing, but Puckett got enough of that to send Justice to the wall. Ball seems to be carrying well tonight. Fun fact: When this World Series was played, Fulton County Stadium had the highest elevation of any Major League park, which doesn’t seem possible.

And now Hrbek is up, and the boos the Braves fans are giving him are much louder than the Tomahawk Chop has been this series. And I’d much rather hear that. Give me real passion rather than canned, half-hearted, racist chanting any day.

Kent Hrbek grounds to first, pitcher covering. Three outs.

Bottom 1 – Twins 0, Braves 0

Jack Morris pitching.

Lonnie Smith flies to center. One out.

In case you were wondering, Morris is still touching the brim of his hat and then the back of his hat after every pitch. At least he’s consistent?

Terry Pendleton lines to left, Two outs.

Both those balls carried farther than I think the Twins fielders were expecting. It’s a bad night for pitchers who leave the ball up.

And now they provide a lovely stat for Ron Gant, saying he tied a World Series record with his 0-for-6 night last night. And then he promptly grounds to third.

Ron Gant grounds to third. Three outs.

Top 2 – Twins 0, Braves 0

They just showed a (probably) 90-year-old man in the crowd, staring at home plate while holding his cane, with the awe-struck smile of a 7-year-old on his face. If that’s my future, I’ll take it in a heartbeat.

Brian Harper doubles to center.

Justice looked weird running for that ball. It’s like he though it he took longer strides, he’d get to it faster, but instead it just made him look like an awkward gazelle.

Now they show two stats: In the first eight games of the postseason, the Twins batted .317 with runners in scoring position; last night, they were 0-for-10. This is where the analytics people tell you that clutch hitting is a myth and that all players and teams will eventually settle to their normal levels of production if given enough “clutch” at bats. That, or they’ll break into your house while screaming “REGRESSION!”

Shane Mack is up, and he needs some regression of his own. He’s 0-for-12 in the series.

Shane Mack strikes out. One out.

He looked completely clueless that at bat, and has for most of this series. Maybe this entire postseason is his regression to the mean.

Mike Pagliarulo singles to left, Harper scores, Pagliarulo to second on the throw. Twins 1-0.

Outstanding jump by Harper there. He took off with the hit and didn’t slow down for a second, even when Belliard missed the ball by about two inches in shallow left, and even when Smith came up throwing. Smith’s throw almost air-mailed Olson at the plate, which allowed Harper to score easily. And now the Twins have scored first in all four games this series.

Greg Gagne strikes out. Two outs.

Gagne looked about as bad in that at bat as Mack did in his. Of course, Mack was a much better hitter in 1991 than Gagne, so that’s not a good comparison.

Now, with Morris batting, the announcers mention that he hit a home run in batting practice, as if that means he has any chance at succeeding in this situation. It’s the second at bat of Morris’ career, after a random one in the 1987 season. He pitched twice in the 1984 World Series, but didn’t bat because they used the DH in every game in that series, regardless of who was at home.

Apparently that was a thing they used to do all the time – just like they would alternate which league had home field advantage (which they should still do, IMO), they would alternate whether to use the DH in every game or have the pitcher bat in every game. To make it even more confusing, they switched it up – if the NL had the home field advantage, the DH was used in every game. They ended that ridiculousness in 1986, switching it so that they’d follow the rule of home team’s league. That move makes sense, although Buck and McCarver are talking like Tom Kelly doesn’t like that switch, that he’d prefer it all one way or all the other.

It’s possible, though, that Kelly said that because of watching at bats like this one that Morris is having against Smoltz.

Morris strikes out. Three outs.

Bottom 2 – Twins 1, Braves 0

Morris is sweating up a storm here. The cover of the DVD I’m watching says the game-time temperature was 72 degrees, which is far hotter than any Minnesotan has ever dealt with (/sarcasm), so that could be part of the problem. I don’t know if it’s the sweat or what, but Morris seems to be having trouble controlling the bottom of the strike zone.

Of course, it’s also possible that I don’t know shit about pitching.

David Justice grounds to short. One out.

It’s amazing how often Gagne made hard plays look pretty easy.

Sid Bream strikes out. Two outs.

Morris got him chasing several low pitches, which further proves that I don’t know crap.

Greg Olson walks.

That’s somehow his fifth walk of the series. The Twins are pitching him like he’s Babe Ruth (phrase stolen from the announcers), but I think it’s more a symptom of how weak the bottom of the Braves lineup was rather than respect for Olson.

Mark Lemke singles to center, Olson to second.

In that at bat, we learned that Lemke’s nickname was “dirt.” Because he hustles and is always dirty. (Puts on liberal hat) You don’t see black players described that way very often, do you? (Takes off liberal hat).

But yah, that hit. It was hit right at Puckett, who was playing too deep to do anything about it (that's at least the second hit for the Braves that fell in front of a too-deep Puckett this series), but for some reason Gladdenstache cut off the ball and made a spinning throw towards third. Might have been better letting Kirby handle that one, Danny.

Rafael Belliard fouls to right. Three outs.

Top 3 – Twins 1, Braves 0

Gladden flies to center. One out.

Knoblauch flies to center. Two outs.

Gant’s catching them just fine, guys. You don’t need to keep testing him.

Puckett singles to left.

His bat speed was so fast. I don’t know how he followed up that big leg kick with such a quick swing, but that was part of Kirby’s mastery of the game. Just amazing.

Hrbek flies to short. Three outs.

Bottom 3 – Twins 1, Braves 0

Ah, there’s the “Hrbek, buy a vowel” sign! I was wondering when I’d see that.

Smoltz is up, and there’s our first reference of Smoltz growing up as a Tigers fan idolizing Jack Morris. Like sands through the hour glass, or something like that.

Smoltz strikes out. One out.

Pat O’Brien is interviewing commissioner Vincent, who was asked what he thought of last night’s game. His response: “I’m just happy to be here. I had a great view.” Does he know that was one of the best World Series games ever? Does he know what a baseball is?

Smith strikes out. Two outs.

Dammit, Buck just said “Morris is in a grove” and “Jack Morris is right tonight.” You know what’s coming…

Pendleton homers to right. Braves 1, Twins 1.

I’ll be honest, I don’t believe in jinxes. But there are plenty of people who do, and I respect all beliefs.

Gant singles to left.

Jack Morris isn’t in a grove anymore, is he, JACK BUCK?

(Insert monotone chanting that sounds like the a entire crowd has joined a cult)

Gant steals second.

Gant picked a pitch that bounced. Good decision-making there.

Gant to third on wild pitch.

Gant picked another pitch that bounced. Remember what I said about Morris and the bottom of the zone? Maybe I was right about something.

Justice walks.

See, if Morris keeps throwing shitty pitches, the fans will think that terrible chant actually had something to do with it. He’s gotta get Bream here to shut them the hell up.

Getting to a 2-0 count won’t help that, though.

Pitching coach Dick Such is visiting the mound, and I honestly think that’s his first mid-inning mound visit of the series. I hadn’t noticed how unusual that was (at least compared to today) until I saw him out on the mound.

Bream grounds to pitcher, unassisted. Three outs.

PITCHING COACHES SHOULD ALWAYS VISIT MOUND.

Top 4 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Harper singles to left.

Two at bats for Harper, two balls that outfielders missed by inches. He has been on base constantly this series. Too bad Scott Erickson had to have a personal catcher, or else Harper might have made a difference in Game 3.

Tim McCarver on why teams should hit and run, or something: “It’s like a golf swing. It’s a game of half swings.” Sure, sure.

Mack grounds into a fielders choice, Harper out, short to second. One out.

This is fine. Mack’s a faster runner than Harper anyway.

Pagliarulo singles to left, Mack to third.

There was a weird cut in the action there. We lost about 10 seconds.

Anyway, great hit and run. Belliard at short broke to second with Mack trying to steal, and Pagliarulo hit it right in the hole. You don’t usually see hit and runs designed to go through the hole at short.
And now with Gagne up, Buck and McCarver are talking about a squeeze play.

Mack caught stealing, catcher unassisted. Pagliarulo to second. Two outs.

And there’s the failed squeeze play. It goes as a caught stealing by Mack, but it was Gagne missing the bunt that caused it. (But really, it was Smoltz throwing a nasty slider that caused it).

Seriously, though, did the announcers have the Twins’ signs? Or did Kelly tell them when he wanted to try something like that? That’s some incredible foreshadowing. They had to know it was coming, right?

Gagne strikes out, catcher to first. Three outs.

Bottom 4 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Weird that Kelly was playing for one run there. He must have been convinced that Morris was fine, despite struggling last inning. Otherwise, why play for one? I know that Morris was on deck, but Gagne was good enough that he could be trusted in an RBI situation.

Or, maybe not, since he blew the squeeze play.

Olson strikes out looking. One out.

Lemke doubles to right center.

Puckett let that ball get under his glove, but McCarver thinks Lemke would have tried for second and probably made it anyway, and I have no reason to doubt him. This time.

Belliard flies to left. Two outs.

And now another aspect of National League ball. The Braves “cleared the pitcher,” meaning they got Smoltz up with two outs in an inning instead of leading off. The Twins failed at this last inning, so Morris will be leading off the fifth. It’s the little things.

Smoltz grounds to second. Three outs.

Top 5 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Morris grounds to short. One out.

Jim Kaat is talking about how deep Puckett plays in center field, saying it’s a combination of coming up playing in the Metrodome and having lost a step. McCarver counters with “he may have lost a step in the field, but he hasn’t lost a step at the plate,” because one of the most important aspects in successfully hitting a ball is how fast you are.

Gladden flies to center. Two outs.

This has not been a good series for Twins outfielders.

Jack Buck just said this is “sweater weather” in Atlanta. Game time temp was 72, and Morris has been sweating all game. But sure, we’ll go with sweater weather.

(I’m a Minnesotan, so I just can’t fathom 72 being “cold.”)

Knoblauch strikes out. Three outs.

Bottom 5 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Halfway through the game, it’s 1-1. Smoltz vs. Morris brings out the best in each other, for sure. That or the World Series atmosphere does.

Ted Turner lives his dream.
And then they show Jane Fonda bear hugging Ted Turner in a very obvious “this is my man and you can’t have him” look, while Turner calmly eats popcorn with a “damn right” look on his face. Oh, and Jimmy Carter is on the other side of Turner. Talk about life goals for Turner.

Smith singles to left.

Oh, hey, it’s this inning! Just keep the camera trained on home plate, camera people. Trust me on that.

Jane Fonda, longtime political activist who several times took the side of Native Americans in disputes with the government, is shown doing the Tomahawk Chop with to her soon-to-be husband. There are no words.

Smith steals second.

Harper is mad at himself, but he had no chance. The pitch bounced, and Morris is slow anyway.

Pendleton doubles to center, Smith out, center to second to home. Pendleton to third. One out.

Three things about that play:
Ouch.
  1. That was absolutely terrible baserunning by Smith. McCarver is – correctly – tearing him apart for that one. Smith started that play on second base, the ball was hit over Puckett’s head and to the wall, and he got thrown out at home. Completely inexcusable. Easily the worst baserunning play of his career, and it will remain that way for exactly two games.
  2. Smith plowed into Harper at full speed like a linebacker on a blitz. The Braves have been waiting to do this since Gladdenstache kicked Olson in Game 1, and they finally got their chance. Seeing that play for the first time in 25 years, it’s shocking how hard he hit Harper. Nobody would have been surprised if Harper had been knocked out by that. That was straight up dangerous – you can see why it’s banned now.
  3. Harper hanging on to that ball is the most amazing thing about that play. That might have been the best defensive play of his career.
Smith’s in the dugout getting treatment, looking like he’s completely miserable. And he’s the one who delivered the hit. Man. How could Harper recover from that to keep catching without a break? I’m sore watching that.

Gant walks.

That was one of those famous “unintentional-intentional” walks. It wasn’t a true intentional walk, but Morris was obviously not going to throw a strike that at bat.

Pendleton out advancing, catcher unassisted. Gant to second. Two outs.

And as if the last play wasn’t enough, Harper let the ball bounce awkwardly off his leg high in the air, then was able to dive back to tag out Pendleton trying to come home. A great play in any situation, but especially so considering he just got more or less run over by a semi. It’s not often your catcher single-handedly saves two runs in the same game, much less the same inning.

Justice flies to left. Three outs.

If Major League Baseball arbitrarily decided to end the World Series right here, with the Twins up 2-1-1, Harper would have been the MVP. Luckily, Bud Selig wasn’t the commissioner yet they let them keep playing.

Top 6 – Twins 1, Braves 1

The Braves fans are booing … what, exactly? Bad baserunning? I guess I get that. If anything, they should be giving polite applause to Harper for what he did that inning.

(Yes, I know there’s no such thing as polite applause toward your opponent in the World Series. Just go with it, OK?)

Puckett grounds to second. One out.

There was awkward skip number 2. Are we missing the “station identification” breaks or something? In-game commercials for … (quickly searches to see what was on CBS in the fall of 1991) … Major Dad or Murphy Brown?

Hrbek grounds to second. Two outs.

Hrbek checked his swing three times that at bat. He looked completely fooled by Smoltz. They even showed Kelly yelling toward Hrbek exasperatingly, which honestly probably happened a lot in the time they spent together.

Now they’re singing the praises of Harper. Release three times by three organizations. Sent to the minors at age 27. Rudy, Rudy, Rudy, etc. 

Harper grounds to shorts. Three outs.

The Twins are acting like they’re allowed to tie in the World Series. You’re gonna need at least 2, guys.

Bottom 6 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Bream flies to left. One out.

You can mark it down. It was the bottom of the 6th of Game 4 where Jack Buck first starts commenting on how great the series has been. And it seems like both teams are almost acting like that. Like they collectively decided to take this inning off to reflect on what was happening and how they got here.

Olson grounds to pitcher. Two outs.

Random Joe Torre sighting in the crowd.

Lemke flies to center. Three outs.

Top 7 – Twins 1, Braves 1

Jack Buck just introduced the Spanish broadcasters for this series, saying their names with a perfect Spanish accent. I don’t see good ol’ Joe Buck doing something like that.

Mack strikes out. One out.

A check-swing on a pitch at his eyes. Mack is an automatic out at this point.

Also, Carl Willis is warming up. Morris is coming out if the Twins get a baserunner. They show him in the dugout looking resigned to his fate.

Pagliarulo homers to right. Twins 2-1.

I’ve long remebered Pags’ Toronto home run. For some reason, I’ve long forgotten that one. That was such a huge home run. The Twins are now nine outs from a 3-1 series lead.

Gagne strikes out, catcher to first. Two outs.

Now here’s an interesting move. You’re up 2-1, with your ace pitcher about to come to bat. He’s on short rest, but he’s been on a roll in the last few innings. Do you let him bat with two outs so he can continue the game? Or do you try the pinch-hitter, and trust your bullpen to get the last nine outs? Kelly chose the latter.

Gene Larkin hitting.

I think I’d have done the same, and not just because I don’t want to second-guess a two-time World Series winning manager. The Twins bullpen had been great all season and into the postseason. They should be able to get nine outs.

Larkin grounds to first, unassisted. Three outs.

TIME TO STRETCH/BREATHE

Bottom 7 – Twins 2, Braves 1

Smoltz is pissed on the bench. He made Pagliarulo look bad on two curveballs, then threw a fastball that Pags hit out. He probably thinks he blew the series.

Carl Willis pitching.

Jeff Treadway hitting.

Again, they’re accusing Willis of throwing a spitball. Since they’re ignoring what Morris is doing but talking about Willis, I’m gonna go ahead and assume every ball Willis threw that season was soaking wet.

Treadway flies to left. One out.

Pat O’Brien talking to Torre and Ted Simmons, two old catchers, about the Harper/Smith collision. They had nothing interesting to say about it.

Tommy Gregg hitting.

And now Smoltz is out of the game. Pitched almost as well as Morris did, but left the game trailing 2-1. Game 7 might be fun.

You're damn right we went trick-or-treating in that.
Again, they say the night is “cool enough” to let Willis blow on the ball. Seriously, did we lose 20 degrees from the opening pitch to now? Can I make a snarky comment about wussy southerners not being able to handle the cold? No? Halloween Blizzard?

Gregg strikes out looking. Two outs.

McCarver is talking to an umpire about whether Willis is throwing a spitter. While the umpire is dodging the issue directly,

Smith homers to center. Twins 2, Braves 2.

Guess that’s one way to correct shitty baserunning – make sure you only have to jog.

Pendleton flies to left. Three outs.

Top 8 – Twins 2, Braves 2

Seven innings played, tie game, both aces out of the game, the entire season depending on the next two innings … this is fine. I’m fine.

Mark Wholers pitching.

Jeff Blauser playing short.

Gladden grounds to third. One out.

Great play by Pendleton. He was playing up looking for the bunt and only had time to stick his glove out to his side to snag it. Saved a sure double.

The announcers are just randomly chuckling at nothing now. This series is getting to everybody. And there’s still a long way to go.

Knoblauch walks.

BRAVES FANS ARE DOING THE WAVE. IN THE WORLD SERIES! Granted, I’d rather sit through nine innings of the wave than nine seconds of the Chop, but still. Doing the wave in the eighth inning of a tied World Series game should be grounds for losing all your remaining home games for that series.

Please?

Mike Stanton pitching.

Bobby Cox says it didn’t matter if Stanton faced a lefty or a right. But Puckett batted .406 against lefties this year.

Puckett flies to right. Two outs.

.406 is still less than a 50 percent success rate, after all.

Knoblauch steals second.

No throw on that play, because Stanton kicks his leg to eye level. He’s practically begging runners to steal on him.

Hrbek strikes out, catcher to first. Three outs.

Ugh, I can’t breathe.

Bottom 8 – Twins 2, Braves 2

They showed Pendleton getting his leg stretched out after coming off the field. He was reacting as though his leg was getting chopped off. If I remember right, he was hurt during the 1987 World Series, too. Just has bad luck against the Twins, I guess.

Gant grounds to third. One out.

Every batted ball makes me flinch even today, 25 years after this game happened.

Mark Guthrie pitching.

Kelly brought in Guthrie to face the two lefties, Justice and Bream. Justice at this point was a career .311 hitter against lefties, and Bream was likely to get pinch-hit for. So.

Justice strikes out.

Brian Hunter hitting.

Hunter flies to right. Three outs.

Just don’t listen to me.

Top 9 – Twins 2, Braves 2

Hunter playing first.

Here’s half-Series MVP Brian Harper leading off the ninth. Somehow, he does NOT look like he has a concussion or any other sort of injury from that collision. If I had been catching on that play, I’d STILL be hurt. (Mostly because I was 10 in 1991, but still).

Harper flies to right. One out.

Justice again looked awfully awkward running after that, and he made a nice sliding catch there.

They do an extreme closeup of Sid Bream methodically taking apart a baseball in the dugout. He even used his teeth to really get in there. But really, the players are handling this Series perfectly fine. Everything’s fine.

Mack flies to right. Two outs.

Zero. For. 15.

Scott Leius hitting.

Seems controversial to take out Pagliarulo, who was 3-for-3 with a home run, but Kelly knew what he was doing. Pagliarulo’s 1991 slash line against lefties was .188/.316/.250, while Leius’s was .305/.427/.445 

And plus also, they just replayed Leius’ home run in Game 2, which came off lefty Tom Glavine. So yah, make that move.

Leius lines to left. Three outs.

Buck originally called that ball a base hit before it hung up just enough for Smith to catch it, because baseball is cruel and I hate it and this game is dumb.

Bottom 9 – Twins 2, Braves 2

Leius playing third.

Olson grounds to short. One out.

Gagne never looked better than when he was going to his right to field a grounder. So smooth.

Lemke triples to left.

Did I mention I hate Mark Lemke? I imagine 25 years ago I was making guttural noises, or saying stuff like “come on!” or spilling my Shasta all over myself. Now, I can appreciate the unlikeliness of such an unknown player being a hero in the World Series. But I still hate him.

Sneaky move by Kelly there. He told Guthrie to walk the next batter, wait for Cox to announce a pinch-hitter, THEN switch pitchers again to make Cox make another move. All of this, again, is being predicted perfectly by Tim McCarver. He’s still saying stupid crap, but he’s also doing a good job of telling us what the managers are thinking in this series.

Blauser walks intentionally.

Francisco Cabrera hitting.

Steve Bedrosian pitching, batting seventh.

Al Newman playing third, batting ninth.

Jerry Willard hitting.

Four player moves between pitches! A double-switch and a double pinch hitter. It reminds me of a line I heard Bob Costas say once: “If you’re keeping score at home, stop!”

(Yes, I kept score at home.)

OK, Jack Buck, take it away:

"That’s gonna be a winner for Atlanta! The runner tags at third. Here’s the throw from Mack. HERE’S LEMKE! He is … ou … SAFE! SAFE! SAFE! SAFE! They called him safe, and Atlanta wins, and we’re tied two games apiece.”

So. Yah. Good ol’ Jack really butchered that call. I know Game 3 was never ending, and this one was tight throughout, but he made two pretty bad mistakes in the ninth inning here. That’s a great World Series moment kinda ruined by his call.

A very good picture of the final run.
Note Harper's glove not touching Smith
Secondly, both Bedrosian and Harper were absolutely, 100% adamant that Harper tagged Lemke there. They are livid, screaming at the umpire. Unfortunately, the camera shot CBS showed for the live shot was from the first base side by the Braves’ dugout, so we didn’t get a great view of the actual play at the plate. The next two replays, still from the first base side, showed it better: Harper tagged Lemke with his elbow, not his glove. Considering everything involved, that was an incredible call to get right in that spot. Replays showed it clearly; I don’t know how the umpire could have seen that so well at full speed.

And poor Harper. After two brilliant plays earlier in the game, it ends on one where he couldn't quite get it done.

Oh, I forgot:

Willard flies to Mack, two outs, Lemke scores. Braves 3, Twins 2

So here we are. Four games into the World Series, now tied 2-2. The game-winning run in each of the last three games came in the home teams’ final at bat. Jack Buck is exhausted and not seeing things correctly, the players are openly gnawing on baseballs in the dugouts, and I probably have an ulcer.
And there are still three games to go.


Wednesday, December 5, 2012

1991 World Series: Drama too Huge to be Hyperbolized

The Teams
American League: Minnesota Twins (95-67) - Second World Series (Won in 1987)
National League: Atlanta Braves (94-68) - First World Series

What Happened
There's an underlying sentiment among Twins fans that not many baseball fans outside of Minnesota are likely to know about. Hell, there are a lot of Minnesotans who might not know about it, at least not consciously. But there are many Minnesotans who will say, when asked, that the greatest Twins game ever was Game 6 of the 1991 World Series. It's a perfectly good game to pick, mind you, one of the true greats in World Series history. But it pales in comparison to Game 7, which is on almost everybody's short list of greatest games ever played. Remind those Game 6 apologists about Game 7, and they'll likely either reluctantly backtrack - "Oh, well, yah, that one was pretty good, too" - or stubbornly refuse to budge - "I don't care, I still think Game 6 was better."

Again, there's nothing wrong with picking Game 6, and there's an obvious reason that longtime Twins fans often lean toward that one: Kirby Puckett. For years, Twins fans had been defending Puckett's prowess to other baseball fans. Telling a Twins fan that Puckett was "one of" the best players in the game wasn't good enough; if you weren't willing to concede that he was the absolute best player in the game, you were making an enemy. In 1991, Puckett could do no wrong. So imagine, then, seeing the Twins facing elimination in the World Series, needing someone to come up big, and seeing Puckett step up and deliver. The hero to scores of Minnesotans delivered on the biggest stage, in a sport where the hero is so often an anonymous afterthought, a person chosen at random for their moment in history.

What Puckett did in Game 6 is legendary, revered to the point where it approaches a religious experience. After telling his teammates he would carry them to a win that night, he tripled in the first inning, leaped against the left field wall to rob an extra-base hit in the third, and hit a sacrifice fly in the fifth. And then, of course, was his game-winning home run in the bottom of the 11th. In one game, Puckett had convinced the rest of baseball what Twins fans already knew: that this guy had no peer.

So yah, it makes sense that Game 6 is the game many Twins fans point to. Their hero became a legend. It's OK.

It's OK for another reason, too. Twins fans don't need to claim Game 7, because Game 7 belongs to the ages. It was a game with drama too huge to be hyperbolized, a game too magnificent and improbable to be  described as merely a Twins game or a Braves game. It was a game that belonged to baseball alone, a game that elevated baseball.

It wasn't just that it took 10 innings for anybody to score, for there have been many 1-0 baseball games that were snoozers. It wasn't just that Minnesota native Jack Morris threw 10 shutout innings, because while he was brilliant, he was also often lucky. It was because both teams put runners on base in nearly every inning, only to have their rallies fizzle out by a great defensive play or a single clutch pitch. The drama, the nail biting, didn't let up for nine innings. Description failed those watching; Jack Buck, who called more great games than anybody really had a right to, stopped trying to contextualize Game 7 about halfway through, instead saying, repeatedly, "This has been a great game."

So what was Buck so awed by? The details. The Braves put two runners on with one out in both the third and fifth; Morris got 2-3 hitters Terry Pendleton and Ron Gant consecutively to end both innings, punctuating the fifth with an impossible-to-hit forkball that froze Gane and led to an exaggerated fist pump from Morris. John Smoltz pitched out of jams in five straight innings, including getting Puckett to strike out to end a threat in the third and getting cleanup hitter Chili Davis to ground into a 3-6-3 double play in the sixth.

And then came the 8th inning. Lonnie Smith led off Atlanta's half with a single, followed by Pendleton ripping one to left-center that even Puckett couldn't catch. But instead of scoring easily, Smith hesitated and stopped at second base - possibly fooled by a fake double play by Chuck Knoblauch and Greg Gagne - and only made it to third. After a walk and an out, Morris got Sid Bream to ground into a 3-2-3 double play, with Kent Hrbek catching the return throw while pumping his fist.

In the bottom of the 8th, it was the Twins who put two runners on with one out. After an intentional walk to Puckett - he walked three times after the sixth, Atlanta openly telling any other Twin to beat them - Hrbek came up with the bases loaded. Hrbek had famously hit a grand slam for his hometown team in the 1987 World Series, and he seemed poised to be a hero again. But his soft line drive went right to Mark Lemke at second base, and Lemke stepped on second for the double play, and the tension grew.

Games 6 and 7 weren't the only great games of the series. Games 2, 3, and 4 were one-run games, with Games 3 and 4 in Atlanta absolute classics that would be remembered among the all-time greats if it weren't for the final two games. Even Game 5, the one that ended with Atlanta winning 14-5, was tight, with the Braves only leading 5-3 entering the 7th inning. But after those first six games, and after the first seventh inning of Game 7, the drama was done. There was no more worrying about whether someone would win or lose, because there was no longer going to be a winner and a loser. These two teams had essentially tied; the winner was now going to be determined by mere chance.

It was the Twins, of course, who finally broke the tie in the 10th: Dan Gladden's broken-bat bloop double followed by Knoblauch's sacrifice and a pair of intentional walks to Puckett to Hrbek, all of which led to Gene Larkins' series-winning hit. The Twins fans who still had a pulse cheered loudly deep into the night, but not quite as loud as they had the night before after Game 6. We couldn't. We were too exhausted. And whether Game 6 or Game 7 was the greatest game in Twins history, it doesn't really matter, because they happened on back-to-back nights, capping off the greatest World Series of all time.

MVP
Jack Morris came home to Minnesota after more than a decade in Detroit to teach the young Twins pitchers how to win. He did more than was expected. He started opening day. He started the All Star Game. He started Game 1 of the ALCS. He started and won Game 1 of the World Series. And then, he took the ball for Game 7 and never gave it up.

Scores  
(Home team shaded; winners in Bold)

Atlanta225 (12)31430
Minnesota534254 (11)1 (10)

The List
I'm ranking all the World Series, from worst to best. Here are the ones I've done so far:

1. 1991 - Minnesota (A) def. Atlanta (N) 4-3
2. 1975 - Cincinnati (N) def. Boston (A) 4-3
3. 1924 - Washington (A) def. New York (N) 4-3
4. 2001 - Arizona (N) def. New York (A) 4-3
5. 2011 - St. Louis (N) def. Texas (A) 4-3
6. 1912 - Boston (A) def. New York (N) 4-3 (1 tie)
7. 1992 - Toronto (A) def. Atlanta (N) 4-2
8. 1947 - New York (A) def. Brooklyn (N) 4-3
9. 1972 - Oakland (A) def. Cincinnati (N) 4-3
Numbers 10-19
Numbers 20-29
Numbers 30-39
Numbers 40-49
Numbers 50-59
Numbers 60-69
Numbers 70-79
Numbers 80-89
Numbers 90-99
Numbers 100-107

Game 7s
Simultaneously, I'll rank all the Game 7s. The ones that have appeared in my countdown so far:

1. 1991: Minnesota 1, Atlanta 0
2. 2001: Arizona 3, New York (A) 2
3. 1960: Pittsburgh 10, New York (A) 9
4. 1924: Washington 4, New York (N) 3
5. 1997: Florida 3, Cleveland 2
6. 1912: Boston (A) 3, New York (N) 2 (game 8)
7. 1946: St. Louis (N) 4, Boston (A) 3
8. 1975: Cincinnati 4, Boston (A) 3
9. 1925: Pittsburgh 9, Washington 7
10. 1926: St. Louis (N) 3, New York (A) 2
11. 1962: New York (A) 1, San Francisco 0
12. 1979: Pittsburgh 4, Baltimore 1
13. 1955: Brooklyn 2, New York (A) 0
14. 1952: New York (A) 4, Brooklyn 2
15. 1971: Pittsburgh 2, Baltimore 1
16. 1940: Cincinnati 2, Detroit 1
17. 1972: Oakland 3, Cincinnati 2
18. 1987: Minnesota 4, St. Louis 2
19. 1958: New York 6, Milwaukee 2
20. 1986: New York (N) 8, Boston 5
21. 1968: Detroit 4, St. Louis 1
22. 1931: St. Louis (N) 4, Philadelphia (A) 2
23. 1973: Oakland 5, New York (N) 2
24. 2002: Anaheim 4, San Francisco 1
25. 1982: St. Louis 6, Milwaukee 3
26. 1947: New York (A) 5, Brooklyn 2
27. 2011: St. Louis 6, Texas 2
28. 1965: Los Angeles (A) 2, Minnesota 0
29. 1964: St. Louis 7, New York (A) 5
30. 1957: Milwaukee 5, New York (A) 0
31. 1967: St. Louis 7, Boston 2
32. 1945: Detroit 9, Chicago (N) 3
33. 1909: Pittsburgh 8, Detroit 0
34. 1934: St. Louis (N) 11, Detroit 0
35. 1985: Kansas City 11, St. Louis 0
36. 1956: New York (A) 9, Brooklyn 0